Hello Friends' List and random internet readers. I'm going to step out of a maven's
shoes for a little while and write a report just for fun for a change.
THE PEACE BOAT REPORTS
MARCH 5 TO APRIL 7, 2005
Or: How I spent my 2005 winter vacation.
By Arudou Debito, Sapporo, Japan
This site is organized thus:
PREAMBLE: HIGH HOPES FOR THIS TRIP
PART ONE: PRELUDE TO BOARDING THE BOAT
PART TWO: LIFE AT SEA WITH A JAPAN IN MICROCOSM
PART THREE: EARNING MY KEEP
PART FOUR: JAMAICA, SLAVERY, AND HOME AGAIN
PREAMBLE: HIGH HOPES FOR THIS TRIP
(email sent to my Friends' Lists, slightly revised)
Date: Sun, 20 Feb 2005 00:42:59 +0900
To: Arudou Debito at home
Subject: Thoughts: Slavery, overseas travel, and comics
ASSORTED THOUGHTS
ON A FEVERISH NIGHT
On discrimination, slavery, going abroad, and comic books
By Arudou Debito
February 19, 2005
Hello Friends. This is not one of my usual essays. I have been writing and
rendering a current project all day, and, after getting more than a third of
it done in a six-hour rush, I went to bed thoroughly exhausted at 9PM
tonight. However, suddenly, about two hours later, here I am again wide
awake, hammering out an essay which simply will not let me sleep until it is
done.
This may seem like a mere blog entry. But bear with me. I promise there
will be a payoff at the end.
I have had a few nights in my life like these--as a child growing up Upstate
New York, in college at Cornell or UC San Diego, in my adult life when I
realized that certain choices had to be made, etc. And always, I let my
mind wander until the creative muses, daemons, random neuron firings of the
dream world, whatever you'd like to call it, finish igniting inspirational
fires inside me. Then I would get up and scribble away, or make some
decisions that would become, as it would turn out, watersheds way down the
line. Stones put in place on the Go board that would only later clearly
make all the difference.
So let me unload three stones weighing heavily on my mind tonight:
1) THOUGHTS ON TRAVELLING OUTSIDE OF JAPAN FOR THE FIRST TIME IN FIVE YEARS
I have lived close to half my life overseas. Yet looking back to where I
came from, I have few wistful memories of "home". I feel little affinity
for the United States, and short of some high school and college friends (I
am long estranged from my parents; they didn't like my
naturalizing into
Japan), I really can't imagine, if I were to show up at an American airport
someday, anything like a "homecoming": A scene of someone running across
baggage claim just to embrace me. Moreover, in Post-9/11 America, I fear
being viewed with suspicion at the American border: "So many millions want
an American passport, and you gave yours up?!", were the comments of former
friends I had the US Government, one of whom thought I was somehow
"betraying" his country by choosing Japan over America. Not all that
extreme an attitude, actually: If those few hundred people who gave up
their US citizenship every year have to get listed in the Congressional
Register, imagine how US Customs would treat me now.
But this year, as it turns out, I will be going back to the US again.
Twice. One reason is for business; my university has ties with UC Santa
Cruz, and I have been tapped to spend three weeks with our eager English
students in California this August. But the second occasion is purely
accidental. From March 11 until April 7, I have been invited to join
something called the Peace Boat (<http://www.peaceboat.org>)
as a volunteer,
teaching about racial discrimination occurring in Japan. I board the boat
at Rome, disembark at Jamaica, and fly back to Narita via New York. Turns
out I will have to overnight in New York City, and provided that I don't spend the
night in the
airport, stranded like nonpassported Tom Hanks in the movie THE TERMINAL, I
might just be in the Big Apple the night of April 5 or 6, 2005. "Would
anyone rush to the airport specially to meet me?", remains the question.
Given that I have had little reason to be homesick in the nearly-unbroken
sixteen years I've lived in Japan, I'm not sure I want to know the answer
either way. It might break the spell somehow.
2) THE VISION QUEST OF THIS JOURNEY
But there's more to tonight's musings than just something which may be
construed as self-pity. An obvious theme of this Peace Boat trip will be
"Discrimination"; the PB organizers were sagacious enough to go beyond
Japan's commonly-held view of "jinshu sabetsu" [racial discrimination]
as
something that only happens overseas (a la South African Apartheid or
Segregation in the American South). Not in Japan, of course, as it
mythically has no racial minorities to discriminate against!
But another surprising theme, which came to me tonight, will be "Slavery".
The Economist just happened to review three books that I decided to make my
Peace Boat reading (no trashy novels for me anymore!). I'll mention each
title and why it matters as separated paragraphs:
"BURY THE CHAINS--Prophets and Rebels in the Fight to Free an Empire's
Slaves", by Adam Hochschild (Houghton Mifflin 2005), promises to tell
me
what sorts of activists managed to wean two major world powers (Britain, and
secondarily the United States) off one of the world's most diabolical (and
economically viable, especially in the latter country's case) systems ever devised
by humankind: the ownership of human beings as property.
"THOUGH THE HEAVENS MAY FALL--The Landmark Trial that Led
to the End of Human Slavery", by Steven Wise (Da Capo 2005),
will tell me how the 1772 James Somerset trial in Britain's courts laid the cornerstone
for the end of slavery in Britain.
"KING LEOPOLD'S GHOST--A Story of Greed, Terror, and Heroism in Colonial
Africa", by Adam Hochschild again (Mariner Books 1998) will tell me
about
the evils of the Belgian Congo (yes, the place that inspired Joseph Conrad,
and later director Francis Ford Coppola, to write about Hearts of Darkness).
This is a chronicle of one of the modern world's first international social
movements, and how activists without the internet, or even telephones (this
took place in 1890s-1910s!), could turn whole nations against a country
committing genocide (5 to 8 million or so dead!) for increased rubber
output--in a world addicted to the economics of Imperialism.
All these books, handed to me after just one chance magazine article, will
hopefully give me some insight on how I can likewise turn Japan away from a
bad habit--of seeing racial discrimination as an inevitable part of human
interaction, defended even in Japan's courts as "rational discrimination".
And as an added bonus, I will be disembarking from the Peace Boat in Montego
Bay, one of the old-world capitals of the slave trade. (That's within
character: Some of the world's best beaches, and here I am visiting former
slave plantations!)
I'm not a terribly religious person, but this all seems so incredibly
convenient. A path that is just unfolding before me will probably increase
my sensitivity to broader issues of history and the mistakes of humankind,
and hopefully make me better able to make a stronger case someday in the
quest for an anti-racial discrimination law in Japan.
Finally,
3) A COMIC BOOK
In another burst of inspiration, last November 2004 I sat down and
storyboarded out some ideas for a comic book. I won't get into the story
here, but it's written in Japanese as a picture book to be read aloud in
school. Aimed at children 5 to 7 years old, I hope to teach them that the
growing number of their classmates with international roots (a product,
among other things, of the 40,000 international marriages every year in
Japan) who look a little different on the outside are still the same human
beings inside. Catch them while they're young, one hopes, and they may grow
up more tolerant of differences (it certainly worked for me when I had an
African-American teacher in fourth grade; but that's a story for another
time).
Anyway, I'm rendering the comic in pen and ink and crayon. Yes, I'm drawing
it myself. Don't scoff; back in high school my favorite subject was
art--oils, acrylic, and cartooning--and after winning an award in a state
competition for my comic strip "Pantherman" (a panther was our high school's
sports symbol), I thought about becoming a graphic artist. Seriously. You
can see an example of my drawing in the form of a political cartoon for the
Japan Times, March 30, 2004, at
<http://www.debito.org/immigrationsnitchsite.html>
(once at the site, page down to see it)
So tonight, in a burst of penning and inking, I finished rendering (waiting
to be colored) the final eleven of the 24 pages, which occasioned me going
to bed so early. And, thanks to a lucky afternoon of phone calls two days
ago, I managed to make appointments with six (yes, six!) children's book
publishers in Tokyo next month before I board the Peace Boat. Here's hoping
that it all means something in the end.
http://www.debito.org/kakumaruchancover.jpg
And that's it. I feel much better after writing this out. I think I can go
back to sleep now. Thanks for reading. Best wishes, Arudou Debito in
Sapporo
February 20, 2005
ENDS
////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
THE PEACE BOAT REPORT
MARCH 5 TO APRIL 7, 2005
Or: How I spent my 2005 winter vacation.
PART ONE: PRELUDE TO BOARDING
////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
I had an amazing March. I was a whole month on the road staying with friends and
going around the world. But I do have to admit: On March 5, loading my suitcase for
a week in Tokyo before heading overseas, I felt a little fearful. I hadn't left Japan
even once in five years, and would be heading for places where neither English nor
Japanese would avail me of communication as smooth as I was used to. Money would
be different, time zones would be different--by crackey, everything might be different!
And what if I got sick, or somebody wanted a tip (I HATE giving tips; I find it--pardon
the pun--gratuitous) and I was unwilling to cooperate or unable to understand...?
And what about those border police, who in this age of terrorist paranoia might go
all gimlet-eyed at a Caucasian with a Japanese passport...?
Pause and realize: I have been in Hokkaido too long, becoming a regular Japanese
ojiisan used to having things "just-so" and fretting over trifles. So I
gave myself the same advice I have always given my students: just go, and make do.
Things would work out somehow. And how, they would.
////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
MARCH 5-10, 2005. TOKYO, JAPAN
As I have no university classes in January through April (only occasional exams to
proctor and grade--and I got those out of the way very quickly), I had time to leave
Hokkaido early and spend time with friends. I stayed the duration of the Tokyo jag
with Chris Pitts, of Amnesty International Japan Group 78, who had a spare room and
a flexible enough spirit to let me spend my days as I liked. I complied, for my Tokyo
schedule was soon full.
Whenever I go somewhere for an extended period of time nowadays, I send advance notice
to my mailing lists--to see if anyone down south has any need for a guest speaker
etc. People did. I got to speak for Amnesty (see handout for speech at http://www.debito.org/amnesty030905.html),
Temple University, and Tokyo Institute of Technology on matters relating to activism
and the Onsens Case.
What happened at the Tokyo Tech lecture (guest speaking for an English class) may
be of particular interest to readers. The audience was comprised of exchange students
from a dozen countries discussing issues of Japaneseness in English--timely, as I
needed to be easied back into the mindset of an international crowd.
The most interesting question came from a Chinese student, who clearly had issues
with me claiming I am Japanese (surprisingly--or perhaps not--most PRC Chinese I
talk to find my situation hard to swallow). He stood up an asked if he could take
a class poll of the Japanese students in this English class--to see if they considered
my claims of Japaneseness valid.
Yes, I was a bit startled by this--his premise was presumably that Japaneseness (moreover
one's identity) was determined by popular vote, not personal choice. So I asked if
I may correct one caveat beforehand: "One problem you might be having could
be due to 'linguistic acclimitization' (the linguists out there probably have a more
specific term for this phenomenon). What I mean is, I've been speaking in English
for ninety minutes, in 'gaijin' prototype. If I could just speak in Japanese for
a bit, that might make a difference on first impressions. Mind if I do?" Not
minded.
So I launched into my standard lecture about the Onsens Case (with jokes, puns, and
catty remarks about the logic underpinning discrimination) all over again for about
fifteen minutes. That seemed to make a difference. I asked the Chinese gentleman
if he still wanted to survey the class. He demurred with a smile and joined me for
lunch.
Afterwards, I asked the student over a bento if he would ever naturalize into another
country. He said flat out that his parents and family would never understand or allow
it. Understandible. But when I asked him the same question with the qualifications
that he had fallen in love with a Japanese, had children with that Japanese, had
lived in worked in Japan for half his life, and was intending to spend the rest of
it here as well, he was not so clear in his answer. I concluded: "Of course
the opinions of your family and peers matter to you now. But you're only in your
early twenties. When you reach forty like me and if you share my lifestyle, you might
see things differently. After all, I've lived your life a second time over, and what
people around me think has come to matter to me much less. Quite frankly, I've come
to the conclusion that David Bowie is right when he sang: 'Nobody cares what you
do; please be yourself to death.'" ("Makin' My Love", from album Day-In,
Day-Out 1987. Okay, now this essay is gettting self-indulgent...)
But the Tokyo week was not all just lecturing people. Last February, I created a
24-page comic book entitled "Kakumaru-chan's face looks different" (Kakumaru-chan
no kao wa chigau). It's about a little boy who looks like both his round mommy and
square daddy in a land where everyone looks round--with interesting playground results.
(See cover at http://www.debito.org/kakumaruchancover.jpg).
Storyboarded in a fit of inspiration last November, "Kakumaru-chan" got
rendered over ten days in pen and ink and crayons (don't scoff--you can create magical
colors and textures with wax, as Batik masters in Indonesia and high school recipients
of my Christmas cards can attest). Aimed at 5- to 7-year-olds, "Kakumaru-chan's"
message is that a person is not a matter of what's outside--it's what's inside. This
is not exactly a sentiment only brain surgeons can comprehend, but it all too often
gets forgotten in the conditioning and socializing of people over the years. Anyway,
I've always wanted to nip these sentiments in the bud at an early age, so out the
comic came.
And out promoting it I went. After looking at bookshelves at my local supermarket,
I contacted seven major Tokyo children's book publishers for a hearing. Six complied.
So the Monday through Wednesday I met with two per day. Guess what? Cold-calling
means you can pretty much bet money on a culture of "no". It made no difference
that I had been published elsewhere (yes, they all knew my publisher Akashi Shoten;
two even knew my books JAPANESE ONLY, and my name). Still no. It doesn't help that
"Kakumaru-ha" happens to be the name of a radical leftist group ("Revolutionary
Marxist Faction") with violent underground tendencies. I promised to retitle.
Still no. One publisher, to my utter suprise, wanted me to rewrite the book and have
it introduce several countries, their faces, and their favorite foods. Me: "So,
what you want me to do is promote stereotypes? That's precisely the opposite of what
I'm trying to do with Kakumaru-chan!" I took my meishi back and left early.
Fortunately, the lessons I was trying to get across in the story were clearly not
all that hard to grasp--people I met later on the Peace Boat wanted color copies
of the story for their social circles and NGOs. Here's hoping. Anyone out there interested?
Conclusion: One week in Tokyo and I was already exhausted. And worried that things
might get worse overseas. If you think I'm a trouble magnet here in Japan, you should
see me as a tourist!
////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
TAKE OFF: ROME, ITALY, MARCH 11-16, 2005
My past travelogues/travel trouble magnet mishaps are duly catalogued as follows:
EUROTREKS 1996
http://www.debito.org/residentspage.html#eurotreks
where I take my wife and toddler kids Interrailing throughout Europe.
AMERICATREKS 1997
http://www.debito.org/residentspage.html#americatreks
where I realize that America is now the foreign country.
CYCLETREKS 1999
http://www.debito.org/residentspage.html#cycletreks
where I first jump on my mountain bike and shed a lot more than just a few pounds
around Hokkaido. Possibly my best essay series ever.
CALIFORNIATREK AUGUST 2005
http://www.debito.org/californiatrek2005.html
where I travel around one of my past habitats and reflect upon paths not taken.
Peace Boat (more about them in Part Two) flew me out from Narita to Rome via Naples,
on Alitalia. A long flight over Siberia with a center seat, a video console that
didn't work, and food that was only slightly above average, I took the time to get
used to being in White society again. I know this may sound a little funny, but I
consider many parts of my experience here (especially since I rarely actually feel
like a "foreigner" anymore) to be a form of "deep cover" in an
Asian society. When this goes on well over a decade, half of that without break, there
is a little mental recalibrating necessary when you go back. I'll be painfully honest:
after looking at Asian faces every day for so long, I have to admit that at odd times
I have looked in the mirror and wondered why my eyes are green and my nose so big
(honestly, it's not all that massive in terms of physics). Why? I had grown to expect
to see every face before me to be Asian (especially in an area like Hokkaido, where
the non-Asian population is lower than the national average). Now, aboard Alitalia,
where there were more stewards than stewardesses, and they were all taller than I
was used to and either descendents of Romans or their invaders, I found myself using
oversimplifying Japanese methods of social science. Romans or invaders? I kept having
to caution myself against painting peoples in such broad strokes.
Touching down in Naples, then Rome, was also jarring. Bags took an hour to come through,
people drove on the wrong side of the road, advertisements were a little on the garish
side, and buildings actually had a sense of style. My first night was spent in a
four-star hotel (all other hotels in town were booked due to the concurrent Rome
Marathon, if not by a few pilgrims waiting for the fading Pope's clock to run out).
Breakfast was immensely edible for a change and I spent the next few days just walking
around Rome.
Rome,
like Florence, Paris or Washington DC, is one of the great cities to perambulate--as
there is usually something to see around every corner (particularly compared to the
architetctural desert that is just about any Japanese city), not to mention a nerve
net of piazzas to settle down in for a break, a drink, or a quick meal. Anyway, I'm
not going to turn this essay into yet another tour guidebook: I just want to say Rome
left me with a very favorable impression, and not just because it was a sunny weekend--the
first one of the Spring and a city flush with runners soaking up sunshine and Italian-food
carbohydrates. I have a feeling that no matter what the weather, Rome would offer
something stimulating to do. I spent one day doing the Coliseum, the Forum, and an
Escher exhibition. Another day (yes, eight hours in one building--St Peter's) within
the Vatican. Another day in the Vatican Museums (I never thought I would find museums
fascinating--I truly am middle-aged), and finally one day just walking around town--eating
when I got hungry, drinking at a cafe when I got thirsty, and just keeping entirely
to myself and loving every minute. If I'm not careful, I'll wind up spending my twilight
years touring Europe... Japanese citizenship or no Japanese citizenship.
And guess what: I had no trouble this time being a Caucasian bearing a Japanese passport.
Italian Customs just waved me in, barely giving me a second look. Soft middle-age
is lending a softer edge to my travels too, I guess. A perfect start to a trip that
would grow more challenging once I hit the sea.
////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
COMING UP IN PART TWO:
JOINING UP WITH THE PEACE BOAT
AND RESETTLING BACK INTO JAPANESE SOCIETY IN MINIATURE
Arudou Debito
Sapporo
April 26, 2005
PART ONE ENDS
PEACE BOAT
REPORT PART TWO
LIFE AT SEA WITH A JAPAN IN MICROCOSM
Hi All. I'm surprised by the positive reception I've gotten for the first two
installments (i.e. Preamble and Part 1) of my Peace Boat Reports. Given that many
readers on my Friends' List have joined within the past couple of years, when I've
mainly issued reports and updates about social issues, I thought a digression like
this would be jarring. Guess not. Many 1) seem to be welcoming the break, enjoying
something more personal from me for a change, and 2) have heard of the Peace Boat
and want to know what it's like. They clamor for the next chapter. Well, here it
is:
///////////////////////////////////
PEACE BOAT REPORT PART TWO
LIFE AT SEA WITH A JAPAN IN MICROCOSM
///////////////////////////////////
By Arudou Debito (http://www.debito.org)
May 11, 2005
I first heard of the Peace Boat about seven years ago, when an activist I used to
work with was invited aboard as an instructor. When my turn came, the circumstances
behind the invitation were a little amusing:
Last December, I was down south teaching a 3-day intensive course at a Senmon Gakkou
in Sendai. On the evening of December 4th, once my 8-hour class finished around 5PM,
I shinkansenned down to Tokyo to speak at a panel discussion on "patriotism",
sponsored by Mindan, a Zainichi Korean action group. After my usual habit of talking
too much, I found I was running a little late for the last shink north. So I ducked
out before things ended, whereupon one of the audience members did the same and met
me in the corridor. After introducing herself as a coordinator on the Peace Boat,
she said:
"I enjoyed your speech tonight. One of our members saw you speak at the Peace
as a Global Language Conference last September on foreign crime [speech text at http://www.debito.org/pglconference092604.html]
and recommended you. I'd like to know when you'd be free to come aboard and teach
about racial discrimination in Japan."
I pulled out my schedule book. "When would you have me?"
"Next March 16 to April 2."
"Got no classes then. Sure. Glad to." I pencilled it in, parted with thanks,
ran off to meet my train, and had arrived back in Sendai at midnight before what
had just transpired could really sink in.
After some of my friends heard about my invite, they volunteered loose-leaf opinions
about things they'd heard about the Peace Boat. PB apparently was started up by activists
who were rather left of center (among them former Diet member Tsujimoto Kiyomi, the
toppler of corrupt giants such as LDP kingpin Suzuki Muneo). A couple held that the
PB is a haven of bran-burger hairy-legged hemp-bag-toting Marxist Anarcho-Syndicalist
hippies who take advantage of the sealed environment to engage in physical free-for-alls
(okay, so I'm sexing the opinions up a little; dramatic license). The point is, rumors
abound about what the PB is and is trying to accomplish. Thus the public interest
in this series of reports, I guess.
Anyway, Peace Boat's goals, structure etc can be found in their own words at: http://www.peaceboat.org/english/wtpb/index.html
including the following history:
====================
Peace Boat was founded in 1983 by a group of Japanese students who were angered
by the Japanese government's censorship of history textbooks regarding Japanese military
aggression prior to and during World War II. They chartered a ship to travel to the
regions of concern with the objective of discovering for themselves the truth about
Japan's invasions of Asian countries and effecting a people-to-people reconciliation.
====================
Sounds comfortably left-wing and idealistic, no? Unfortunately for me, I'm naturally
cynical when reading any organization's mission statement--one gets that way after
years of dealing with bullspit in politics and government. So, what follows are my
personal experiences aboard the Peace Boat, for what they're worth, and unsexed-up:
/////////////////////////////////////////////
APRIL 16, 2005. CIVITAVECCHIA, ITALY
was where and when I boarded the boat. It was deserted, as people were finally getting
an overnight ashore after more than two months afloat. Departing Feb 2, its previous
ports of calls were Kobe, Shanghai, Da Nang (Vietnam), Singapore, Cochin (India),
Mombasa (Kenya), Massawa (Eritrea), Port Said (Egypt), and Tripoli (Libya). It would
then go on to Marseilles, Las Palmas (Spanish Canary Islands), Montego Bay (Jamaica),
Cristobal (Nicaragua), Balboa (Panama), Callao (Peru), Valparaiso (Chile), Rapa Nui
(Easter Island), Papeete (Tahiti), and Honolulu, ending up in Yokohama and Kobe on
May 17 and 18 respectively. Total trek 3 1/2 months. See the itinerary, photo library,
and more about life on board and ports of call at
http://www.peaceboat.org/english/voyg/48/index.html
This was the 48th Voyage on board a ship with a long history, built in Glasgow and
launched (as of this coming June 22) exactly fifty years ago: SS THE TOPAZ (formerly
EMPRESS OF BRITAIN). Registered in Panama, Topaz has a Greek command, a crew from
countries including Indonesia, The Philippines, and Bulgaria, and a capacity of over
1000 passengers and crew (981 were on board this voyage, a record for the Peace Boat).
An excellent website with the full history and layout of the grand dame is available
from:
http://www.maritimematters.com/topaz1.html
Something briefer at:
http://www.ssmaritime.com/topaz.htm
/////////////////////////////////////////////
GETTING THE FEEL OF THE SHIP
Freshly
aboard and with nothing on schedule, I spent a few hours getting used to my room.
It was a single, as large as any business hotel suite I've stayed in in Japan, but
with a cabinet, two closets, a sink, toilet and shower stall, television (with 4
channels--two for closed-circuit movies on continuous replay, one for receiving local
TV broadcasts, and one with an outside view facing the bow), and a double bed. There
was even a complimentary bottle of wine with two glasses. (Join the crowd: I had
taken the liberty of bringing on board a couple of bottles of Italian white wine,
as would anyone going on shore; the most popular thing to buy at any port of call
was, of course, cheap exotic booze). I even had a maid service (my steward, Mr Gun
Gun, was very friendly and thorough, and seemed to actually enjoy making beds). The
problem was, and this would be no fault of the Peace Boat, was that it was right
in the back on an upper deck, making for a couple of miserable days in the Atlantic.
But I'll get to that later.
I then had a look around the ship. The lowest deck open to the public was for teachers
and staff who were living (sometimes four bunks to a room) the life of a college
dorm, with all the excitements and forced sociality due to the lack of privacy that
entails. The next two decks were the garden-variety rooms (I of course did not see
inside them all) of singles, doubles, and first-class suites that grace any passenger
ship. Notably, these decks also contained one major dining hall (suitably called
Topaz) that was either serving food, or preparing to do so, from morning till night.
Topaz was sit-down and formal, avoiding as much as possible a cafeteria atmosphere,
and doing its best to provide food (materials quite influenced, naturally, by the
last port of call) with some gourmet touches (which is essential, as Japanese, especially
the elderly, take their food very seriously, with a very low tolerance for fast-food
settings).
Third deck from the top was where all the out-of-cabin social gatherings went on,
with a movie theater (showing a movie most nights--yes, even TITANIC, although that
attracted well over a hundred thrill-seekers and had to be projected at a larger
venue), a grand hall on the poop deck (i.e. the very back, above the propeller) for
large convocations of several hundred, a smaller hall with a capacity of a hundred
plus, a bar/disco/karaoke/mah jongg area (this is, after all, a boat catering to
Japanese), a common all-purpose open area for pick-up speeches and convocations of
unascertainable popularity, a command and control center for the Peace Boat staff
to carry out morning meetings and publish its daily newspaper, a full bar (called
Hemingway) where most people had a tab, a classroom for about forty people, and finally,
long corridors up and down the sides of the ship for people to sit, knit, read, play
games like Shougi or Go, schmooze or smoke.
The upper decks were mostly outside, with a boardwalk along the sides and up front.
But there was a second restaurant (the Yacht Club) aft offering fast-food-style tubs
of salad, pizza, takoyaki, fries, squid rings, etc., and both indoor and outdoor
seating. It doubled as a Japanese restaurant/bar/enkai zone between 8PM and 2AM every
night for those feeling homesick. There was also an exercise room and outdoor basketball/soccer
court (which attracted the younger passengers), and some classrooms for language
teachers. The topmost areas offered a sun deck, jacuzzi, pool (which, matching the
sea in roughness, was rarely used while I was aboard), and outdoor bar. An extra
deck, according to the abovementioned SS Topaz historical website, has an indoor
pool, but that area was off limits to everyone but crew, strictly enforced.
That gives you an idea of what's on offer, but it was amazing how well everything
got utilized. More on that next time in Part Three of this report, so let me wrap
things up with some information on the demographics of the passengers:
/////////////////////////////////////////////
JAPANESE SOCIETY IN MINIATURE
I don't have any hard statistics, but I would estimate that the boat was, crew included,
about 90% Japanese. This meant the lingua franca for passengers was Japanese, with
the occasional (during my tenure on board) native speaker of English, Korean, Spanish,
or French. Most of the Peace Boat staff seemed at least bilingual in one of the fundamental
communicative skills, and several language teachers (either bilingual or studying
to be) were resident, or brought on board to offer instruction to passengers for
upcoming ports of call. Many of the invited guest lecturers (such as myself) either
were or could speak Japanese, and those who couldn't were provided with very capable
simultaneous interpreters. I was impressed with just how much effort was put into
communication on this boat, with few of the overwrought Japanese worries about how
difficult it must be to deal with people of differences. Probably due to the experienced,
relatively young (in their thirties and forties) progressives who were in charge
of things...
Anyway, of that proportion of passengers who were Japanese, I would again estimate
that over sixty percent were elderly--in their sixties and seventies--retired folk
who were using their pensions to see the world. Not difficult, as the cost of the
Peace Boat (not including onshore excursions or bar tabs) was 1,380,000 yen per person--not
bad for roving room and board for 100 days!
The other forty percent were in their teens and twenties, some touching thirty (The
youngest passenger I met was sixteen, on board alone taking a break from high school.
What progressive parents!). And mostly women. Now, before you think that this is
like Castle Anthrax in MONTY PYTHON AND THE HOLY GRAIL, remember that most people
I associated with were fairly serious activist-types (naturally, as that was what
I was teaching), there to learn something. (I might add that there was, sagely, a
mature aversion to creating more complex relationships. After all, you have to spend
the next several months together, and, as in any working environment, if something
goes pear-shaped it will be uncomfortable dealing with an ex every day.) Some were
taking an emotional hiatus after high school, or after an abortive attempt at a job
or a relationship, and were trying to sort out what to do with their lives.
Consequently, this demographic brought out probably my favorite parts of Japanese
society--a genki social environment. The oldsters, who were not interested in sex,
love triangles, politics, money, or anything but vacationing and having a good time,
were pretty well determined to have one. They sunned themselves, formed societies,
socialized, studied, played games, learned how to dance (the hula, salsa, and shakou
dancing were quite popular), created things out of leftover rubbish, sang, ate, and
drank. And ate and drank. As elderly "gate-ball-and-Go" Japanese society
almost makes a point of accentuating the positive in any relationship they know will
be a daily one (again, for the sake of peace of mind when dealing with exactly the
same people for three and a half months), the atmosphere was quite upbeat. Yes, there
were a few stir-crazy stubborn grumps and cranks, but they were, on balance, ignorable.
The youth, for their part, as usual formed their cliques, sports, arts, and musical
societies, etc. But they knew they were in the minority, and were largely deferential
to the oldies and constructive towards the genki atmosphere. Fortunately, they had
had (by the time I had boarded) enough time to get to know the old farts as people
with common interests, mostly breaking down the rather draconian age-based social
rigidities which arise, again, from the Japanese business, financial, or family settings
that are a feature of a regular society. But, as we shall see later, the Peace Boat
was not a regular society, and for that reason was much more enjoyable.
However, as far as I was concerned, very few people were in my age bracket, i.e.
middle-aged forties. Not to worry, though; after only about a week aboard I felt
quite comfortable and assimilated. The key to that was keeping oneself busy.
And man, how busy I got. I will talk about that in the next installment.
Arudou Debito
Sapporo
May 11, 2005
/////////////////////////////////////////////
PART TWO OF THE PEACE BOAT REPORTS ENDS
PEACE BOAT
REPORTS
PART THREE: EARNING MY KEEP
As I mentioned in previous installments (available at http://www.debito.org/peaceboatreports.html),
I had been brought over by the PB on a round-the-world trip with essentially all
expenses paid. Now it was time to keep my end of the bargain--teach about human rights
in Japan--to a captive audience for two weeks. I viewed it as a great opportunity
to spread the word to sympathetic listeners, of course. It soon became a fine example
of the old adage:
BE CAREFUL WHAT YOU WISH FOR
It probably goes without saying, but like lots of people in education, I am a professional
talker. When I have an agenda and a curriculum, I can talk (and do regularly) for
up to eight hours at a time. Not with the stentorian style of an auctioneer, mind
(although when I really get into The Zone, it comes close), but long enough and intensely
enough to sate even the most absorptive listener. I've learned the value of taking
breaks and letting people digest, but like the Simpsons' joke, "bartenders do
it until you barf", I do it until your brain is full. I can't think of a single
time in my professional career when I really felt as if the audience had outlasted
me, or I had used myself all up.
Until the Peace Boat. Even I was not prepared for the intensity of the experience
on offer there. It took as much as I could give, and then some, with some of the
most avid intellectual cross-pollenization I've ever experienced.
/////////////////////////////////////////////////////
JINKEN TABEHOUDAI -- ALL THE HUMAN RIGHTS YOU CAN EAT
In specific, I was brought on board to teach at Peace Boat's "Global University".
Whassat? Excerpted from the source (http://www.peaceboat.org/english/edu/univ.html):
=============================
What is the Global University?
The Global University is an intensive peace studies programme which combines study
on board the ship during one of our voyages with exposure programmes in selected
regions that the ship visits...
On each voyage there is a number of study modules on offer, each focusing on either
a regional conflict, such as the Israel-Palestine conflict or the Balkan conflict,
or an issue of global concern, such as the environment or human rights. Each module
takes place during a section of the voyage, during which experts from around the
world join the ship to offer onboard lectures and workshops. Study programmes in
the ports of call during that section of the voyage complement the onboard study,
while longer exposure tours, which leave the ship in one port, spend an extended
period of time on land, and then return to the ship at the following port, provide
an opportunity to experience first-hand one of the regions under focus through a
comprehensive range of study and exchange activities...
The Global University is divided into an English-language and a Japanese-language
programme. Both are open to everyone onboard.
=============================
This voyage, the 48th, offered three GU units: 1) "Wars in Asia: Past, Present,
and Future", 2) "Multicultural Coexistence: What can we do?",
and 3) "Challenges for a Sustainable Society". More details on what
happened in each unit at http://www.peaceboat.org/english/voyg/48/index.html,
but I would be teaching part of Unit 2, during the nine-day Atlantic stretch between
Las Palmas (Spanish Canary Islands) and Montego Bay (Jamaica), where there would
be no land (it is one of the larger stretches of ocean anywhere with no islands whatsoever),
and no distractions but what we made for ourselves.
As I mentioned in the previous report, I embarked in Civitavecchia on March 16, a
full week before I would be teaching. Boarding with me were two French passengers,
one a lecturer, the other an interpreter (French to Japanese), who would facilitate
discussion on the first topic of Unit 2--France's recent laws against Muslim headscarves
in state-sponsored Ecole schools--before we stopped off at Marseilles.
Frankly, I felt this section was a middling success. Not the fault of the Peace Boat,
mind, as they prepared Japanese, French, and English simultaneous interpreters who
had breathtaking talent. Nevertheless we wound up in a Tower of Babel situation:
The French lecturer would speak in French, the French interpreter would render it
into Japanese, and another simul would put it into English (through earpieces to
three English-speaking language staff and one Korean NGO professional), without much
lag at all. But very often, as the native French interpreter had a soft voice, often
softer than the simuls speaking into their mics, there would be a drowning-out, if
not a crowding out, of tongues.
But nothing could compensate for a debate that blurred. We could not wrap our heads
around the headscarf issue. The express reason why the French government banned them
in the Ecoles (I specifically asked for the selling point that convinced legislators)
was because they have religious symbolism, creating problems with the separation
of church and state. Ecoles cannot allow religious imagery in a free learning environment.
Fine, but the point was still raised (and not by me--this was a class of 35 very
aware people ranging in age from early twenties to late sixties, from Japan, Korea,
the US, and Britain): were Easter and Christmas holidays observed? Well, they're
legally sanctioned by the government, not religious. What about Christmas trees?
Well, they're not religious--merely seasonal custom. Well, what of the possible claim
that headscarves are merely custom as well?
That was where we diverged into arguments of headscarves being a symbol of women's
oppression. We were provided with burkhas (the head-to-toe women's Islamic public
dress) to try on (I did--how dreadful) to illustrate the point: the intolerances
of certain religious practices vs. the need to allow people who are in France to
be French, learning under French codes of public expression. This meant barring the
importation of customs which are intolerant of local laws and customs towards gender
differences and freedom of expression.
Fine--this was the stronger argument, as nobody disagreed with the argument that Islamic practices
towards women should not be forced upon women in more tolerant societies. But two
problems were never fully resolved to our satisfaction: 1) the underlying French
fear of coexisting foreign enclaves (compared to, say, the British, American, and
even Japanese Chinatowns and Koreatowns); and 2) the apparent double-standard of
Christian-based "customs" holding sway over Islamic "religious practices"
simply because the Christians got there first. If one used the "gender oppression"
argument in the debate, it's stronger. But that's not the one French legislators
cite.
Clearly religious symbolism appeared to be the express public reason, fear of Islam's
oppressive tendencies the underlying reason. Ultimately, we passed it off naturally
like Japanese, as a clear case of "tatemae" [pretext, political exigency]
and "honne" [the real spirit behind the decisionmaking process] and moved
on.
/////////////////////////////////////////////////////
BATTER UP--BRING THE ISSUE HOME
Then it was my turn to speak, to remind people (the PB had foresight that I found
mindblowing, since people educated in Japan generally seem to believe that racial
discrimination is only found overseas) that the standards that we apply to the world
also apply to Japan as well.
My opening speech was to a general assembly (in the PB's largest assembly hall "Broadway",
viewable at http://www.maritimematters.com/topaz7.html)
with a full soundstage, raised platform, and capacity of 550 people. One hitch: it
took place in rough Atlantic seas near the Canary Islands. And believe me when I
say I mean rough--the boat was first pitching, or seasawing front and back, so that
the only people with any respite were those in the center of the boat at pivot point.
(I personally got double-whammied; because my cabin was in the back, I woke up in
the morning riding a roller coaster, trying to get well enough just to leave the
room by shaving and showering while sitting down. Only to find my lecture was in
the very back of the boat anyway.) Once I had gotten reasonably used to the pitching,
the Good Ship Lollipop started rolling from side to side, i.e. without pivot points
offering any sanctuary whatsoever. It must have been comic--if one could laugh without
losing their lunch--to see me up on stage, unable to stand still, prowling back and
forth with the lurch of the ship, almost falling off the edge a few times, with stage
lights hanging down at forehead level threatening to do a Michael Jackson on my hair.
Probably over half the ship was seasick (which is why, I told myself, only a couple
hundred people showed up to listen to me introduce the Otaru Onsens Case), including
the speaker, making this one of my most unusual speeches ever.
(An aside. The first couple of days out in the Atlantic were so bad for this landlubber
that when we made landfall in Las Palmas, the earth still felt to me like it was
moving, swaying, suffering mini-earthquakes that were severely localized. There is
in fact a word for this phenomenon in Japanese--"rikuyoi" (land drunk),
as opposed to "funayoi" (ship drunk), and it was one of the reasons why
I spent extra time on shore trying to get over it--to the point where I made it back
to the boat with three minutes to spare before the gangplank got raised. And yes,
if you're late back to the boat--something the administration frowns upon for obvious
reasons--you get a Yellow Card; twice late means a Red Card and you're expelled from
the voyage. If you don't make it back before the ship sails, you get to the next
port on your own steam and expense. But that didn't stop me from having one of the
most delicious meals ever onshore--garlic octopus, garlic steak and potatoes, garlic
omelette, and garlic something else with two bottles of Spanish table wine with friends.
Anything to shake the motion sickness before embarking on a leg of the cruise where
we wouldn't even sight dry land for at least a week. End of aside.)
/////////////////////////////////////////////////////
GETTING OVER IT AND INTO IT
So on went my classes at Global University. Given a free hand to plan the arc of
my course, since I was the only one teaching, I started off with:
1) Establishing the mindset behind discrimination. I positioned myself as
an onsen owner and told the class to try and persuade me to take my "Japanese
Only" signs down. Great fun (even adopted my classic patented blue-collar ojisan
accent). Guess what--for every point they made I had a counterpoint (I employed every
argument made to me by the owners in real life), and they couldn't dissuade me.
Conclusion: once a person has made up their mind to discriminate (people can think
of reasons to justify ANYTHING, as history has shown), there is no way you can persuade
them otherwise (horse being led to water but not being made to drink, is the axiomatic
analogy). Which is why we need laws to stop the bigoted, who, left to their own devices,
will discriminate. http://www.debito.org/otarulawsuit.html
2) Establishing what having no laws against it does to people in Japan. Showed
the permutations of discrimination, its spread, and the reasons given for how people
justify keeping the status quo (allegations of foreign crime, fear of giving people
of perhaps questionable loyalties too many rights, opening the floodgates of "me-too"
minority privilege...). http://www.debito.org/roguesgallery.html
3) Bringing it to the interpersonal--showing that internationalization of
Japan isn't just on the horizon: it's already here and always has been. One of our
simul interpreters, a Zainichi Korean born in Japan who speaks three languages, sat
beside me at the lecture table and told us what it's like being a generational foreigner
in Japan. Then we discussed our differences in perspective towards nationality and
identity. Why she would never naturalize, and I did. In nutshell: She--not to mention
her family--always considers herself ethnic Korean first, Japanese second (if at
all), and doesn't feel any dire need to change the status she has always had since
she was a child. As for me, I wanted to be a Japanese citizen precisely because,
among other more important reasons, I had the choice to do so, and I have experience
of being a citizen of a country with full civil rights.
4) Establishing current social policy which targets foreigners. Links to all
that information at http://www.debito.org/foreigncrimeputsch.html
, and http://www.debito.org/whattodoif.html
5) Where do we go from here? And what can you do to help? That's available
at http://www.debito.org/handout.html
And more, since as part of the GU program, at the end of the unit we were to give
a final presentation to the PB in general as to what we had learned. It turned out
to be magic--all 35 or so students broke off into groups to cover a certain topic
(the hard facts, cultural frictions, legal problems, generational feelings towards
differences, future prospects, etc.), with very informed and well-thought-out presentations.
The issue that garnered the most attention was, ironically, the need for PB Japanese
passengers to comment on every non-Asian passenger's acumen with chopsticks. I have
long since learned to pass it off as old folk just trying to be friendly, struggling
for a topic to strike up a conversation with. But the non-Asians both in our classroom
and on the boat in general really took offense--thinking it worth telling the audience
to kindly knock it off. To them (and me as well, when I'm in a mood), it's like damning
somebody with the faint praise of being able to eat like an adult, to raise a glass
to one's lips without knocking one's teeth out, or to zip up one's fly with acuity.
Highlights of the presentation were one professional writer within our midst (a Mr
Kida) reading out an expository essay written specially for the occasion. And the
oldest guy in our troupe, a Mr Hamada, out of the backwoods of Hokkaido and constantly
chasing the thoughts in our lectures like birds (picture of him and me visible at
http://www.peaceboat.org/english/voyg/48/spe/050330/index.html),
stood up and said, "Buy this book!" He held up a copy of JAPANESE ONLY.
"I learned a lot from it!" The book then sold out within hours, a fine
example of the lessons within Malcolm Gladwell's tome TIPPING POINT. I think I'll
savor that moment forever.
But that was not the end of doings. I also gave speeches to the language teachers
aboard, talking about survival strategies within Japan, and how they can cope with
mental gear-grinders (like that old chopsticks chestnut) without going nuts (info
at http://www.debito.org/HAJETspeech.html).
I also attended a panel discussing "What is wealth of a society?", and
held a general "get to know Sensei" Q&A session (entitled by my helpers
cleverly as "Shitsumon Aru Do!"), and gave a concluding general speech
to the PB about what the everyday person could do to further human rights in Japan.
(Nutshell: See something mean and nasty in the mass media? Phone or email them to
complain--that's why they have free phone numbers and websites. Hear your friends
say something a bit off or overgeneralizing about people? All you have to say is,
"Dou ka na, chigau n ja nai?" [I wonder if that's true]--and break the
spell. That's plenty. Just do a little bit--and let people know that silence does
not necessarily mean tacit agreement.) This time, with calmer seas, the hall was
near full.
And it was beyond full when I gave a speech on slavery (my first, in Japanese, no
less--I had six pages of vocabulary notes thanks to the books I had recently read
on the subject (see Preamble Section above). In an area with
a capacity of about 30, around 150 people showed up to hear me try to describe why
slavery existed, how it was done away with in almost every country, and how it exists
even today. This had some resonance, because the very sea route and ocean current
we were on had historically brought slaves from Africa to the Caribbean, where the
majority died in horrible sugar plantations. More on that in Part Four of this series.
/////////////////////////////////////////////////////
GETTING ALL USED UP. ALONG WITH EVERYONE ELSE.
In total, I gave sixteen speeches in a little over a week. I lost my voice in the
process. Instead I got the voices of other guest lecturers and their projects: Mr
Mori Tatsuya, a documentarian who did movies "A" and "A2" on
sociopathic Aum Shinrikyou Cult from the perspective of their members. Mr Ohsawa
Norio, a professional masseur and Tai Chi instructor (he did a late-night jam-session
where he massaged about 200 people for about thirty seconds each--all the while somebody
dressed up in clown garb rang in whether this person was of good health or not; weird
enough to be prime Japanicana. One of my favorite moments on the boat was where I
entered there rather drunk to find one of my 50-year-old newfound obasan friends
from Sapporo asking me what I was listening to on my CD headphones. "Crosby
Stills, Nash and Young"--artists many of the young people on this boat, Lefties
notwithstanding, had never heard of! She knew them, liked them, and unhooked one
headphone from my ear and snuggled up, one headphone each, as we watched the masseur
work over bodies. It was a moment of tenderness that only people who are drunk and
old enough to be platonic can experience.). And a very talented artist and student
of Tibetan Thangka (do a word search on the genre--too elaborate to get into here)
named Don Van Amerongen (whose brother is a famous cartoonist in his own right),
I forged quite a close friendship in a very short amount of time (then again, that's
easier than one might imagine--there's nowhere else to run on a cruise ship so you
might as well be social). There was also a Japanese stage voice instructor named
Takarai Ginrei instructing the oldies on traditional arts, and a world-class Argentinian
and Columbian dance pair (Guillermo and Rebecca)--who were HOT! to look at, and offered
rhythmically-unchallenged passengers incredible Salsa lessons I found simply terrifying
(only because I am petrified of dance floors; still, I gave it a try, if unsuccessfully,
only because one must confront one's fears). Again, photos and reports on these people
available at http://www.peaceboat.org/english/voyg/48/index.html
The point I'm trying to make is, I was certainly not the main attraction of the boat.
I was but one sideshow, one planet orbiting the PB solar system offering one world
view. Picking up the average copy of the daily newspaper, the "Yotsuba"
(four leaf clover, meant as a symbol of happiness and good luck), you could find
no less than 60 events per day, running from 9AM to often past midnight, on the ship
schedule--many events put
on by passengers completely independent of the PB. People learning Mah Jongg and
the game of Go. Classes in English, Spanish, Indonesian... and Yoga. Morning calisthenics.
Table tennis, pickup soccer and basketball matches and tournaments. Hula Dancing,
Shakai Dancing, Belly Dancing, Cheerleading, and Chanson lessons... And the occasional
public performances of same. I realized that given the choices available to people
day in and day out, I had a pretty good attendance to all the events I put on.
/////////////////////////////////////////////////////
And as the waters of the Atlantic changed from cobalt blue to a
shallower sky, and
more floral flotsam and dolphins became visible on the surface, we felt
the chilly
sea breeze give way to the hot, shallow-water-warmed coral caldron of
the Caribbean.
I first sighted the lights of the Turks and Caicos islands--the first
signs of civilization
in seven days, one midnight, as we sailed a route between Cuba and
Haiti down through
to Jamaica. The Caribbean, a wondrous area of the world where short
stretches of
water separate specks and landmasses that are in widely different
stages of development,
reflecting how they were colonized, developed, plundered, and forever
changed in
genetic makeup by overseas imperial powers. It's always been an
impressive place--think
of the some of the great European novels (Treasure Island, Peter Pan,
Kidnapped, Mysterious Island...) the Caribbean inspired. It also was
the scene of some of the more unimaginable examples of human cruelty.
More on that
in my next installment.
Arudou Debito, Sapporo
June 6, 2005
debito@debito.org
http://www.debito.org
PART THREE OF THE PEACE BOAT REPORTS ENDS
Hello Friends. Let me start the new year by finishing up a series long left dangling:
January 1, 2006
The last time I wrote about this trip, which happened between March and
April of 2005, was all the way back in June! Previous
installments with a couple of photos at
http://www.debito.org/peaceboatreports.html
When you see what topic I'm taking on (the whole verdammt institution
of slavery!), you'll see why it took me so long. A bit ambitious,
yes, but let's give it a try:
At last writing, our protagonist was completely drained of his speaking
powers after sixteen speeches in a little more than a week on the Peace
Boat. Disembarking in Montego Bay, Jamaica, he spent his allotted
recuperation days dodging tourist targeting and trying to find traces
of one of mankind's worst crimes against humanity--slavery. He
then went back to the USA briefly for the first time as a Japanese
citizen...
///////////////////////////////////////////
THE CARIBBEAN
A CAULDRON OF WORLD HISTORY AND POLITICS
The Caribbean is one of the most interesting places in the world,
inspiring book after book, one multicultural social experiment after
another (you could arguably see the long-term effects of different
governance systems--Spanish, French, English, American, even Slave (in
Haiti)--in island colonies/nation-states separated by short stretches
of ocean yet wide gulfs in wealth, stability, language, and development
of civil society). A decent introduction to the area is James
Michener's CARIBBEAN, but just to give an overview of how inextricably
linked the region is to world history:
And so on. Sources are Adam Hochschild books BURY THE CHAINS and
KING LEOPOLD'S GHOST, Brown and Kelly eds. YOU'RE HISTORY, and the
abovementioned Michener.
///////////////////////////////////////////
SLAVERY'S EFFECTS ON MANKIND, IN BRIEF
It is hard to discount or depict the dehumanizing effects of one man
treating treating another man as property, and it was widespread enough
to be justified by holy writ, economics, theoretical and scientific
constructs regarding racially-based intelligence and innate superiority
of peoples and civilizations, even by the inertia of precedent, social
order, and culture (cf. the 1858 Lincoln-Douglas debates; http://www.nps.gov/liho/debates.htm).
Why did slavery exist? Think money. You get your labor for
next to nothing--for it is surprisingly easy to scrimp on human
amenities when you can treat employees like cattle. Moreover,
economies of scale in the slave trade can happen relatively easily
(just capture, impress, indenture, or indebt more people), making human
beings into literally "disposable labor". In the Caribbean, it
was actually cheaper to buy new slaves than to feed and "breed"
existing ones.
Moreover, from these cheap inputs you can create such large-scale
labor-intensive super-farming operations (i.e. plantations) with such
competitive advantage that rivals have to procure slaves of their
own. And even if society demands that slaves be set free, the
owners, based upon extant property laws, could seek compensation for
losses--the ultimate deterrent to legislators (usually back then the
landed classes) envisioning enormous fiscal damage to government
coffers for tampering with the status quo.
However, slavery is a self-defeating system. Short of
exterminating everyone you import (which the social justice
practitioners of the day eventually made sure did not happen) or
returning them "back home" (which never really caught on), these people
were here to stay. So were great social divides between rich and
poor, black and white, owner and owned, that ultimately undermined
whole societies--sapping them and entire peoples within them of their
potential. Then there's the fact that slavery encourages cruelty,
given the corrupting spiral of control of owner over owned.
Enforcement of rules and deterrents to runaways and rebels required
fear, through increasingly cruel and horrifying public
punishments. After all, there was nothing to stop owners from
going too far--there were few, if any, legal protections for slaves
against bodily harm (consider how dogs and cattle are allowed to
treated in most societies, particularly if they are seen as a threat to
humans). The frequent slave revolts fomented by this not only
required further cruelty to repress, but also could be so destructive
that all accumulated wealth was lost for everyone.
And I mean everyone--including the spoils for the slaves in the
unlikely event they emerged victorious. Liberated lands, such as
Haiti, tried to utilize remaining infrastructure, but society was by
then so damaged by slavery that it was difficult to start afresh and
succeed. For people wanted compensation, social equity, revenge,
and immediate improvements to their standards of living right away, and
often explosively. Sadly, to enforce social order and run
slave-dependent industry profitably, new leaders often resorted to the
same old tactics, redolent of slavery all over again, and wound up
destroying things even further. After all, once something as
indelible as skin color is used systematically as a method for social
stratification, it's extremely hard for a people to stop believing it
is still not a factor whenever something unsatisfactory happens.
In short, slavery corrupts and destroys.
Yet slavery is a hard habit to break, regardless of the historical
period or modernity of a society. Even after it was formally
banned by contemporary world powers such as England and France, the
trade still went on--even under their flags of those countries.
Slavery still exists today in every country in the world, according to
National Geographic (September 2003, http://magma.nationalgeographic.com/ngm/0309/feature1/index.html).
Although illegal everywhere, YOU'RE HISTORY pp. 374-7 (citing the UN's
conservative estimates) says that people in indentured relationships,
human trafficking, child labor, serfdom, debt bondage, etc. worldwide
still number around 27 million. This is more than double the
entire four centuries of trans-Atlantic slave trade.
Nevertheless, slavery WAS made illegal worldwide, surmounting enormous
social and systemic obstacles. These bear spelling out, if only
to demonstrate that seekers of social justice can always be
successful--for if slavery can be abolished (at least on paper) then
any unjust system can be.
Let me quote at length the person who makes the case best about the size of the giant killed:
=====================================
"...[P]icture a
world in which the vast majority of people are prisoners. Most of
them have known no other way of life. They are not free to live
or go where they want. They plant, cultivate, and harvest most of
the earth's major crops. They earn no money from their
labor. Their work often lasts twelve or fourteen hours a
day. Many are subject to cruel whippings or other punishments if
they do not work hard enough. They die young. They are...
in bondage, part of a global economy based on forced labor. Such
a world would, of course, be unthinkable today.
"But this was the
world--our world--just two centuries ago, and to most people then, it
was unthinkable that it could ever be otherwise. AT THE END OF
THE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY, WELL OVER THREE QUARTERS OF ALL PEOPLE ALIVE
WERE IN BONDAGE OF SOME KIND OF ANOTHER [my emphasis], not the
captivity of striped prison uniforms, but of various systems of slavery
or serfdom. The age was a high point in the trade in which close
to 80,000 chained and shackled Africans were loaded onto slave ships
and transported to the New World each year. In parts of the
Americas, slaves far outnumbered free persons. The same was true
in parts of Africa, and it was from these millions of indigenous slaves
that African chiefs and slave dealers drew most of the men and women
they sold to Europeans and Arabs sailing their ships along the
continent's coasts. African slaves were spread throughout the
Islamic world, and the Ottoman Empire enslaved other peoples as
well. In India and other parts of Asia, tens of millions of
farmworkers were in outright slavery, and others were peasants in debt
bondage that tied them and their labor to a particular
landlord... Native Americans turned prisoners of war into slaves
and sold them, both to neighboring tribes and to the Europeans now
pushing their way across the continent. In Russia, the majority
of the population were serfs, often bought, sold, whipped, or sent to
the army at the will of their owners.
"The era was one
when...'freedom, not slavery, was the peculiar institution.'
...[A]nyone looking back in time would have seen little but other slave
systems. The ancient Greeks had slaves; the Romans had an
estimated two to three million of them in Italy alone; the Incas and
Aztecs had slaves; the sacred texts of most major religions took
slavery for granted. Slavery had existed before money or written
law.
"[Regarding the
majority of trans-Atlantic traffic to the New World]... So rapidly were
slaves worked to death, above all on the brutal sugar plantations of
the Caribbean, that between 1660 and 1807, ships brought well over
three times as many Africans across the ocean to British colonies as
they did Europeans. ....From Senegal to Virginia, Sierra Leone to
Charleston, the Niger delta to Cuba, Angola to Brazil... the Atlantic
was a conveyer belt to early death [in plantations between] Baltimore
to Rio de Janeiro and beyond.
"Looking back
today, what is even more astonishing than the pervasiveness of slavery
in the late 1700's is how swiftly it died. By the end of the
following century, slavery was, at least on paper, outlawed almost
everywhere. The antislavery movement had achieved its goal in
little more than one lifetime."
(Hochschild, CHAINS, pp 1-3)
=====================================
How that happened is the subject of books above, and I won't get into
it as it involves a lot of political, ahem, horsetrading and even some
historical accident. But one constant in the equation is tireless
lifetime effort by activists, sometimes even single individuals
(particularly Clarkson, Sharp, and Wilberforce. Not to leave out
Edmund Morel's singlehanded exposure of genocidal slavery--five to
eight million dead--in the Belgian Congo 1890-1910, creating the 20th
Century's first international civil-society social movement.)
Yes, one person can make a difference.
And Jamaica's Montego Bay, by the way, happens to be one of the biggest
former slave ports. Let's switch our style back to first-person
narrative and rejoin our protagonist as he disembarks from the Peace
Boat and wends his way through the crowds:
///////////////////////////////////////////
APRIL 2-5, 2005
MONTEGO BAY, JAMAICA
It was overwhelming. I was now back in an Englsh-speaking society
(ostensibly--the strong accent and the prevalence of patois forced me
to recalibrate my understanding of English quite a bit) as a White boy
in a completely Black environment, standing out not only for my color
but also my economic status. Prices for taxis, ice cream,
exchange of JPY into Jamaican dollars, beach-grilled Jack Chicken, and
any services requiring a tip skyrocketed whenever there was no price
listed or agreed upon at the outset (even then, a tip was often
demanded at the end of things, with hours of bonhomie spoiled by
last-minute berates). Streets were filled with cars driving like
go-karts, every corner and nearly every shop blared with sound of
reggae or some rap mix, and the smell of ganja and barbecue all
contributed to making me woozy and distracted and hungry. People
were friendly, but the targeting and the heat and the hubbub were
draining until I went to a church and just luxuriated in reading
tranquil tombstones, as well as catching a chance wedding. One of
the people I struck up a conversation with in the pews showed me around
town a little in exchange for lunch (lamb stew with rice and beans) and
a few beers at the supermarket.
That's where I found the best way to deal with the sensory
overload: Drink. Everyone else was at it. And since a
15% grenade-bottle of wine was cheaper than a comparably-sized bottle
of 100% cranberry juice, my discoveries of supermarket-cheap Peanut
Cream Rum and Ginger Wine combined with the need to keep my water table
up blurred reality from photographic to impressionistic. But it
did not blunt my charge of trying to find some relics of what happened
to probably all of the ancestors of the people around me.
I put myself up not within the hotels with private beaches, but on a
roadside mid-range hotel with a front porch overlooking the ocean on
sands open to the public. When people asked me what tour I might
like to go on, I asked for a taxi to some of the major local sights
(particularly former plantations on the hilltops, overlooking valleys
which still did not have electricity and running water in places;
having that taxi later stranded in one of those areas at night, where
car headlights were the only source of light, showed me vast income
inequality even in one of the Caribbean's most touristy spots).
When I asked my guides if they could take me on a "slavery site tour",
they shrugged and suggested a few plantations, such as the
well-preserved Barnett and Greenwood great houses. There is,
according to Hochschild there is not a single slave dwelling left
standing in Jamaica (not surprising--they were not built to
last). A few slave hospital ruins, a rusting sugar boiler here
and there, but as Hochschild puts it:
=====================================
"The experience of
visiting such spots is not like that of seeing Nazi concentration
camps, where the tours are organized, the visitors numerous, and the
crematoria and other evidence of deliberate murder so painfully
visible. Rather, it is like seeing the remnants of the old gulag
camps strewn across Arctic Siberia: few pilgrims, nothing
preserved... with nature taking over... It is the visitor, and
not a tour guide, who must ask the questions... How many slaves
were worked to death feeding this boiler? How many had their arms
crushed in the rollers of the mill [which juiced sugar cane before
boiling]?
"Much better
preserved and restored are some of Jamaica's plantation[s]... A
few of these are occupied by wealthy families; others have been
converted into small hotels or charge admission for tours given by
women in period costumes... As in the American South, the old
days have been commercially burnished into a time of gracious comfort,
with the assumption that the tourist will identify with the
slaveholder, not the slave... [Y]ou can find life-size mannequins
of a slave maid serving tea to her seated white mistress. There
are, of course, no mannequins of women field laborers."
(CHAINS pp 363-4),
=====================================
Historically, this is eminently unsatisfying. Especially given
where we were. Consider the conditions, especially when compared
to the American variety, which I had been taught was pretty bad:
=====================================
"Caribbean slavery
was, by every measure, far more deadly than slavery in the American
South. This was not because Southern masters were the kind and
gentle ones of GONE WITH THE WIND, but because cultivating sugar cane
by hand was--and still is--one of the hardest ways of life on
earth. Almost everywhere in the Americas where slaves were
working other on sugar plantations, they lived longer. Besides
planting the cane, they had to fertilize the soil with cattle manure
they carried to the fields on their heads in dripping eighty-pound
baskets. The most intense work came during the high-pressure
five-month harvesting and processing season. Hour after hour in
the hot sun, they had to bend over to slash as the base of the talks
with a heavy machete while clearing aside the cut canes with the other
hand. Sugar cane leaves have knife-like edges and sharp points
that can jab the eye, cheek, or ear of a tired or unwary cutter.
Slaves had none of the protective gear available to day: safety
boots, aluminum arm and leg guards, canvas gloves with leather
palms. Furthermore, in the lush tropics where land was being
fertilized, planted, weeded, or harvested for most of the year, there
was little winter respite from field work.
"The sugar regime
was not the only burden. The West Indian climate brought a raft
of tropical diseases... [T]he Caribbean slave diet was far worse
than that on the North American mainland, causing nutrition-deficiency
diseases like rickets and scurvy... On average, Caribbean male
slaves were three inches shorter than those in the American South.
"Among the slaves,
almost all the skilled jobs, like maintaining mill equipment, building
sugar barrels, or doing masonry, went to men. This meant that...
the majority of slaves in the fields... were women. The fact that
women did the hardest labor, combined with their abysmal diet, delayed
menarche and brought an end to a slave's fertility by her
mid-thirties. In the mid-eighteenth-century British West Indies,
fully half of all women sugar slaves never bore a child.
"Because of
[this], Caribbean masters depended... on a constant flow of new
slaves... Plantation owners generally felt, as the saying went,
that it was cheaper to buy than to breed. An Antigua planter
[said] that his policy was 'with little relaxation, hard fare, and hard
usage, to wear them out before they became useless... and then, to buy
new ones, to fill up their places'.
"One final set of
grim numbers... When slavery ended in the United States, some
400,000 slaves imported over the centuries had grown to a population of
nearly 4,000,000. When it ended in the British West Indies, total
slave imports of two million left a surviving slave population of only
about 670,000. The tiny French island of Martinique took in more
slave imports over the years than all thirteen North American colonies,
later states, put together. The Caribbean was a slaughterhouse."
(ibid, pp 65-7)
=====================================
That is why it is a shame this history apparently has been lost forever even in a land still frequented by outsiders.
So I gave the plantations a miss. I did hire a driver to take me
100 miles south to the Appleton Estate, makers of Jamaican rum (still a
mainstay of Jamaican exports and culture. The waste product of
sugar--molasses--had to go somewhere, and fermented into rum it became
currency for buying even more slaves!) Yep, not a mention of
slaves anywhere in the rum museum--a few dark faces in historical
drawings, but not in any way alluded to. The trip wasn't a total
loss, however; I was driven by my stoned and Red-Bulled driver at
breakneck speeds (I myself drank and let the inescapable reggae
music transport my fear away) through Maroon country. Maroons
were escaped slaves that took refuge in Jamaica's interior impenetrable
limestone mountains and caves, forming independent communities for
generations. After occasional raids on White coastal communities,
they were finally put down at great cost in 1795. Many of their
descendents still seem to be living to this day in similar subsistence
conditions...
Finally, I decided to just go to the the gorgeous sands like any other
tourist and peoplewatch. As I said, I was on a public beach, and
as such the only White face there. Feeling a little
self-conscious, I just floated in the perfect-temperature water
watching the young Jamaicans (who at this age were shaped like
gazelles! Think singer Grace Jones--she's Jamaican.) frolic and
play water tag with a ball. After a while, some of the preteens
took an interest in me, and a seven-year-old girl, after playing a bit
of catch with me, asked me a question several times. I had a hard
time penetrating the patois, so she just pointed to my arm and said:
"Why are you that color?"
"What, this? Because my mommy and daddy were that color.
Just like your mommy and daddy are your color. But there's
nothing wrong with it."
She nodded and resumed catching the ball, as if her curiosity was
settled. It would be nice to think that maybe I had a hand in
increasing the racial tolerance of one little girl at an impressionable
age.
///////////////////////////////////////////
RETURNING HOME:
APRIL 5-7, 2005
My return flight was Montego Bay to Tokyo, with an overnight at Newark,
NJ. It would be my first time in the US since relinquishing my
American citizenship (see how that all came about at http://www.debito.org/deamericanize.html
), and America had certainly changed since I was last there (in 2000),
to the point where I would hate to be a foreigner there now. I
was worried that my presenting a Japanese passport to a US Homeland
Security official would engender suspicion and secure me some private
time with a rubber-gloved interrogator.
Didn't happen. The INS at Newark looked at my passport, ran it
through the reader, then after taking face and fingerprint scans, asked
me how long I was going to be in the US. One night. He then
waived me through.
"That's it?"
"That's it."
"Thank you for making it so easy for me." The official shrugged and called the next person in line forward.
As I waited for my bags, I made arrangements by cellphone with a friend
in this port of call, Chris, studying international law in a nearby
university. He had already gotten his friends together and was on
his way by car to meet me. We spent the evening first tooling
around a dark and scary part of Newark buying fried chicken from a shop
run by an Ethiopian. But I had a hankering for a roast beef
sandwich (since ham and roast beef is largely insipid in Japan unless
you pay premium prices), so I went across the street (gazing nervously
at some nearby flashing police cars apparently answering some crime),
and took refuge at a Jewish deli run by Spanish speakers.
Withdrawing some money from their ATM, I asked them to make me said
sandwich.
"I don't think we have any bread," the clerk said. Some words tossed around in Spanish. "Nope, no bread."
If this were Japan, the conversation would have ended there with no
sale. But one of the things I like about America is a recurring
"can-do" attitude. Without hesitation, he went over to the
shelves on the other side of the store, brought back a submarine loaf,
asked if I would be willing to buy it, and proceeded to make me an
enormously thick sandwich (another thing I like about America) after
shaving a mound of beefish product off an industrial-sized slab and
putting every possible topping on it. Cost? Three
bucks. Yet another thing I like about America!
Chris and company got us some booze, we headed back to my hotel, and
spent the entire night socializing. Yes, the entire night, just
like old college roomies. Even though this was the first night
we'd ever met. Two of them even wrote blog entries about the
event:
http://www.cominganarchy.com/archives/2005/04/07/curzon-meets-debito/
http://nichinichi.blogspot.com/2005/04/four-internet-tarento-one-night-in.html
Gotta love the Internet.
The next day, I was on my way back to Japan. Through Japanese
passport control without an eyeblink. And not minutes after
clearing customs, I had my first phone call.
It was a reporter from the Hokkaido Shinbun. "Arudou-san, care to comment?"
"Comment about what?"
"The Supreme Court just handed down your decision on your lawsuit against the Otaru City Government."
http://www.debito.org/otarulawsuit.html
"Oh, first I've heard. That was quick. How did it turn out?"
"You lost."
http://www.debito.org/otarusupremecourt.html
"Okay, here's what I think..." and I launched into a speech I'd prepared for this exact occasion.
Right away, I was back into the swing of things. Fighting for my
own version of social justice. Japan had truly dragged me back
home.
Arudou Debito
Sapporo
January 1, 2006
PEACE BOAT ESSAYS END
PS: If you enjoyed this essay,
and would like to see a similar one on my August 2005 trek around
California (now with photos) click here:
http://www.debito.org/californiatrek2005.html
ENDS